
2010-07-11
À propos de la controverse créée par Jacob Tierney

2010-01-24
Le socialisme à l'individuelle
2009-10-10
A conversation between an angry Libertarian and a disabused Idealist

2009-08-20
On nous prend pour des cons ou quoi ?


2009-05-14
En espérant qu’elle regrette un jour ses paroles...
2009-02-16
Quand les Américains font l'éloge du Canada

2008-10-23
On n'arrête pas le progrès ! (sic)

2008-08-03
Une question de valeurs (?)

Curieusement, vous seriez surpris de constater à quel point même les Américains de gauche, démocrates, pratiquement socialistes et anti-guerre à l’os tiennent mordicus à conserver ce droit fondamental de posséder une arme. Même si certaines règles comme celle-ci sont complètement hors contexte en 2008, le petit bout de papier signé en 1776 demeure pour eux une bible à ne pas transgresser.
Remarquez qu’en se mettant à leur place, on comprend un peu plus pourquoi ils continuent de penser comme ils le font : programmes sociaux pratiquement inexistants ou inefficaces, écart flagrant entre les riches et les pauvres, système démocratique chancelant à « deux » partis néo-conservateurs identiques, seule société occidentale où Dieu est un enjeu électoral important dans chaque campagne électorale, police qui n’a pas l’obligation légale de protéger ses citoyens (oui, oui, vous avez bien lu !), état corporatiste où le lobby (donc l’argent) a toujours le gros bout du bâton au détriment de ses citoyens, etc. En gros, dérapage historique oblige, l’individualisme extrême de cette société est en train de les faire plonger dans les bas fonds de l’altruisme humain. Quand ton voisin est une menace plutôt qu’un allié, tu t’armes et tu te protèges. On ne ferait probablement pas mieux.
Voici un bref extrait de notre discussion, notamment les points touchant à l’individualisme. En réponse au commentaire publié ici il y a quelques semaines, mon collègue de droite me cite Ayn Rand :
“Yeah, I'd have to side with the Anglos on this. When you go to Chinatown, everything is in Chinese, with a little English thrown around. But either way, the language issue is trivial compared to other issues regarding the implications of collective rights. Here are some excerpts from the Ayn Rand lexicon that give you a quick gist of what I am talking about:
“Collective Rights”: Since only an individual man can possess rights, the expression “individual rights” is a redundancy (which one has to use for purposes of clarification in today’s intellectual chaos). But the expression “collective rights” is a contradiction in terms. (...) Any group or “collective,” large or small, is only a number of individuals. A group can have no rights other than the rights of its individual members. (...) A group, as such, has no rights. A man can neither acquire new rights by joining a group nor lose the rights which he does possess. The principle of individual rights is the only moral base of all groups or associations. (...) Any group that does not recognize this principle is not an association, but a gang or a mob... (...) The notion of “collective rights” (the notion that rights belong to groups, not to individuals) means that “rights” belong to some men, but not to others—that some men have the “right” to dispose of others in any manner they please—and that the criterion of such privileged position consists of numerical superiority. (...) The notion that “Anything society does is right because society chose to do it,” is not a moral principle, but a negation of moral principles and the banishment of morality from social issues.”
Ce à quoi je ne peux m’empêcher de rétorquer :
“I know very well about what you are talking about, and I just couldn't disagree more. I'm sorry, but the definitions you are citing are perfect examples of sophisms to me. One should look at world history and read more about the two sides of a story before jumping to conclusions so fast.
Now don't get me wrong! I think individual rights are EXTREMELY important and I totally agree with you on that point. In fact, totalitarian societies of the past (and even the present ones!) have shown us how individual rights are so important to us all.
However, we are what we are as human beings because of our associations with others in a manner that goes way beyond the mere "contract" between individuals. It's the whole basis of human nature and preservation: to help and to be helped in an organized and totally altruistic way.
We are who we are as human beings because we created societies and because we recognized that this free association with others should be preserved and cherished with rights and responsibilities for all. And these rights and responsibilities go way beyond the mere individual rights you are talking about.
A whole is more than the sum of its parts and not recognizing that is to neglect the mere fabric of our current societies and their histories. Heck! Even nature and biology work like that! As well as our organization of science... Peer reviewing, publishing, etc.: there are collective rules and responsibilities that govern how these things should be done to give everyone an equal chance of success. It's all altruistic and should be kept like that, otherwise you start getting the sort of corruption we talked about yesterday for your government.
But I guess you just don't see it the way I do and we'll just have to agree to disagree on that subject... In fact, the way we were brought up probably has a lot to do with the way we perceive our current societies and cultures.
As an outsider in this country, I really get the feeling that US citizens are being fed with constant fear of everything by everyone. This probably goes a long way in understanding this individualist and “pro gun” attitude we talked about yesterday: fear of government, fear of others, fear of thieves, fear of elevators, fear of death, fear of fear, etc. Let's all be paranoid about the neighbor, eliminate any kind of altruism and arm ourselves against this invisible enemy! The only “collective” attitude in this is that we are *ALL* afraid... United we stand! In fear...
“There will always be a part, and always a very large part of every community, that have no care but for themselves, and whose care for themselves reaches little further than impatience of immediate pain, and eagerness for the nearest good.” - Samuel Johnson
That quote, I believe, is the result of pure egoistic and egocentric individualism leading to utter disregard for others. To me, that goes against progress, human nature and the mere preservation of our species.
But I guess it's a question of values.”
Conclusion de mon collègue ?
“That was very beautifully said and you make some good points. But, I feel like you interpret the individualist agenda as being completely selfish and neglecting everyone around them. And that isn't so. Just because one may put himself in front of others is nothing more than a rational way of living one's life; a guide if you will. But that doesn't mean that these people are cold-hearted egocentrics... at least I don't consider myself one. I suppose you are right, in the end it all just comes down to values. I personally feel that freedom and liberty are virtues that supersede everything else. I feel that if we were truly free, then those who would like socialized systems can set them up, maintain them, and subscribe to them themselves. That way those who don't want any part in it don't have to partake. But anyhoo, let's just agree to disagree. It was good arguing with you, dude.”
Hé ben.
2008-02-24
Sociologue du dimanche
Il y a des peuples qui ont de la misère à sortir de chez eux. Pas dans le sens d’aller chercher une peinte de lait au dépanneur ou d’assister à un spectacle le vendredi soir, mais bien dans le sens d’aller vivre ailleurs que dans leur environnement immédiat, dans leur province, dans leur état. Souvent limités par la barrière de la langue, les Québécois sont comme ça. Compréhensible, me direz-vous ? Peut-être. Y'a même des Montréalais qui ne sont jamais sortis de leur ville, mais ça c'est une autre histoire...